| Platinum | Sweet Bites Bake Shoppe |
| Gold | Mason Dixon Bakery |
| Silver | Scarlett Cookie Co |
| Bronze | Peggy Ann Bakery |
| Top Pick | Baby Bite Bake Shop |
| Top Pick | Edgar's Bakery and Restaurant |
| Top Pick | L'Etoile Patisserie |
| Top Pick | Little Dipper Bakery and Cafe |
| Top Pick | Parlor Doughnuts |
| Top Pick | Tout Les Jours |