| Platinum | Rosie's Mexican Cantina |
| Gold | Southern Egg Cafe |
| Silver | Big Ed's Pizza |
| Bronze | Peppered Pig |
| Top Pick | Bubby's |
| Top Pick | Domaine South |
| Top Pick | Forever Grateful, LLC |
| Top Pick | Mason Dixon Bakery |
| Top Pick | Mazzara's Vinoteca |
| Top Pick | Purveyor Huntsville |