| Platinum | Cookie Fix |
| Platinum | Mason Dixon Bakery |
| Gold | Sweet Bites Bake Shoppe |
| Silver | Great American Cookies |
| Bronze | Maddie's Cookies |
| Top Pick | Crumbl Cookies - Jones Valley |
| Top Pick | Gigi's Cupcakes |
| Top Pick | Little Dipper Bakery and Cafe |
| Top Pick | Scarlett Cookie Co |