| Platinum | Handel's Ice Cream |
| Gold | Three Scoops |
| Silver | Golden Years Ice Cream |
| Bronze | The Marble Slab Creamery |
| Top Pick | Bruster's Real Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Culver's |
| Top Pick | Dairy Queen |
| Top Pick | Oscar Moon's |
| Top Pick | Pythian Parlour @ Midcity |
| Top Pick | Sam & Gregs Pizzeria |