| Platinum | Rosie's Mexican Cantina |
| Gold | El Herradura |
| Silver | Casa Blanca |
| Bronze | El Monte Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | El Coyote |
| Top Pick | El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | LA Esquina Cocina |
| Top Pick | LA Finka |
| Top Pick | Phil Sandoval's Mexican Restaurante |
| Top Pick | Taco Mama |